But some may wonder whether my assertion that mainly White actors have been responsible for the violence is accurate. Therefore, I'd like to share the following news stories:
- "‘Umbrella Man’ went viral breaking windows at a protest. He was a white supremacist trying to spark violence, police say", Washington Post. Note that the "Umbrella Man" made his appearance at one of the first Minneapolis protests against the murder of George Floyd.
- "White Women Tagging ‘Black Lives Matter’ On Starbucks Caught By Black Protestors", BET.
- "Nearly two dozen arrested in Richmond as weeks of peaceful protest turned violent over the weekend," Washington Post. Note that the mayor of Richmond identified the violent instigators as White supremacists who were outsiders to the community.
- "Why are white supremacists protesting the deaths of black people?", The Conversation.
- "A white supremacist channel on Telegram encouraged followers to incite violence during police brutality protests by 'shooting in a crowd,' according to internal DHS memo," Business Insider.
- "Violence mars Portland protests, frustrates Black community," AP. Note that the troublemakers are not content to limit themselves to causing trouble at protests, but are part of the White violence against minority businesses and neighborhoods in the aftermath of the murder of George Floyd and the ensuing protests.
- "Finley: Violent white protesters hurt cause of racial justice," The Detroit News.
- "Meet the ‘Boogaloo boys,’ the violent extremists attracting members of the US military," Task and Purpose.
- "As Trump warns of leftist violence, a dangerous threat emerges from the right-wing boogaloo movement," Washington Post. Note that members of the Boogaloo movement have been linked to the shootings of police and Federal security guards that took place after the murder of George Floyd.
- "Far-right groups like the “Boogaloo” and “O9A” continue to attract troops and veterans," Military Times. Note that the senior officers of the U.S. military recognize the presence of a far-right element in the U.S. military as a serious problem. Note also the link between these far-right elements and Satanism.
- "A woman accused of throwing Molotov cocktail at a police car suggests a protester gave her the device," CNN. Note that although this woman claimed that Black protestors gave her the Molotov cocktail, the police who investigated her discovered that she was lying. What gave her away was the presence of her fingerprints and the fingerprints of a friend of hers on a note about glass bottles...
However, it must also be noted that there is a deeply dysfunctional element in the American dominant culture. This element consists of people who have based their entire lives and their entire identity on the power they have been able to exercise in order to dominate, bully and ruin the lives of their intended victims. They are the forever "Cowboys" - unreconstructed, unreconstructable, and unrepentant - who demand that the rest of us play the role of the forever "Indians" or the forever "slaves". A woman I recently heard in an online workshop said that bullies have thin skins. I would also add that bullies are not really sure they exist in the world. Being afraid of their own ghosthood, they can only reassure themselves of their existence by trashing someone else's life. The Boogaloo movement, for instance, is one of those far right movements who are trying to push society into chaos so that they can build a fascist, White supremacist empire out of the ashes. These are the Elliot Rodgers of the world, who seek to ruin in order that they may possess. Rather like Satan, aren't they? And if communities of color base their struggle solely on the tactic of mass protest, guess who will come in to hijack the protests!
Therefore, a key response of the historically marginalized, of the communities of color, of the communities which have not been historically dominant must be a response of collective self-organization. By organizing ourselves to meet our collective needs, we build our social power - power which is to be used not to dominate others, but to help ourselves fulfill our own ontogeny, and to help other afflicted communities fulfill their ontogeny. And it is collective and sustained self-organization that is the foundation of successful nonviolent resistance movements - not mere protest. Study Gandhi for instance, and you will discover not only the acts of mass noncooperation against the British, but also his insistence on what he called the constructive program - a key part of an oppressed population liberating itself from oppression by learning to rule itself.
So this brings me to my last comment. Given the weakness of struggles that rely solely on mass protest, and given the ease with which both State and non-State opponents can hijack such struggles, I once again urge the Black Lives Matter organizers and the organizers of the struggles of other communities of color to look beyond mass protest as your go-to tactic. Broaden your knowledge of strategic nonviolent resistance. Please read some good books on the subject. (Maybe one of my future posts will be simply a list of recommended good books!) And please learn the art of strategy!
I leave you with one comparison from military history. World War 1 was almost lost by the British because of one man, Field Marshal Sir Douglas Haig. Haig assumed command of British troops in 1914, and proceeded to launch a number of offensives against the defensive German lines. For over three years, his go-to strategy was to try to wear the Germans down by attrition, and to try to punch a hole in German defenses so that his horse-mounted cavalry could charge to victory. Such a strategy might have worked in the 1800's...but by World War 1, there were these inconvenient little things called barbed wire, machine guns and heavy artillery. The Germans also used a tactic known as defense-in-depth. Haig became highly predictable in his tactics, in the same way that having mass protests day after day for over 60 days in the U.S. in 2020 has become highly predictable. Therefore, the Germans played rope-a-dope with him, costing him several hundred thousand men. Britain was saved from defeat by the entrance of the United States into the war. But did Haig learn from his mistakes? Not at all, according to a quote of his from 1926.
Basing a strategic nonviolent resistance or liberation struggle solely on spontaneous, poorly-planned mass protest rallies in these days should therefore seem about as stupid as relying on horse-mounted cavalry in modern warfare, shouldn't it?
No comments:
Post a Comment